Okay, guys. Now that the dust has finally settled on the Hawkins saga and we’ve all had a chance to breathe, we need to have a real, probably difficult, conversation.
For nearly a decade, this show hasn't just been "streaming TV." It was our cultural anchor. We watched these kids grow up in real-time. We stayed up until 3 AM dissecting frames for clues, theorizing until our brains hurt, and falling in love with a group of outcasts that felt like our own friends. So, when the credits finally rolled on the absolute end... why did it feel so hollow?
Look, it wasn't a total disaster. We didn't get "Game of Thrones-ed." The production was gorgeous, and the cast—as always—poured every ounce of their souls into it. But did it actually land? Did it pay off ten years of our lives? To be honest... I don’t think it did. It felt like the showrunners were so afraid of hurting us that they forgot that the best parts of Stranger Things always came from the pain and the high stakes.
I’ve spent the last few days replaying the scenes in my head, feeling this deep sense of "what if." I wanted an ending that left a bruise. I wanted an ending that respected the trauma these characters went through instead of just healing it with a time-skip and some upbeat music. So, as a massive fan who just can’t let it go, I sat down and wrote out the version of the ending I think we truly deserved.
(Massive spoilers ahead, obviously. Both for the real show and my own sanity-saving rewrite.)
1. The Villain Hierarchy: Henry was NEVER the boss.
One of the biggest letdowns for me was the reveal of the Mind Flayer’s "true nature." It felt so reductive, right? Turning this cosmic, eldritch horror—an entity that felt like a Lovecraftian god in Season 2—into a second-fiddle lackey for Henry Creel? It made the universe feel smaller.
In my version, we flip that script to make Henry even more terrifying. Henry has a god complex; we’ve known that since his monologue in the rainbow room. He’s obsessed with order, dominance, and the idea of a "predator" status. Instead of Henry being a pawn of the Abyss, the twist should have been that he reached a level of psychic darkness so profound that he was actually suppressing the Mind Flayer.
Think about it: the Mind Flayer wasn't "waiting" in the Abyss for all those years; it was being actively harnessed and shackled. This recontextualizes everything. Vecna isn't just a wizard borrowing power—he’s a tyrant who bent a literal cosmic force to his will. It raises the stakes for the final battle because we realize Henry isn't just fighting the kids; he’s holding back a tide of primordial chaos just so he can be the one to rule the ruins. When he loses his grip, the consequences aren't just his death—they're the end of reality as we know it.
2. The "True Form" Boss Fight (The Trap)
The finale we got felt a little scattered—jumping around different locations like a standard action movie without that mounting sense of "oh no, we’re actually doomed." I wanted a two-stage boss fight that would have left us breathless and physically exhausted just from watching it.
Phase 1: The False Victory. The group takes on Vecna in the physical world and the mental plane simultaneously. This needs to be visceral. I’m talking about memories being weaponized, the environment warping into a twisted version of the school dance, and the kids using every trick they’ve learned since 1983. It’s a coordinated, desperate effort. And they win. They kill him. The music swells, the "four gates" begin to close, and they’re all holding each other, sobbing with relief. We think it’s over. We think they’ve won the "safe" ending.
Phase 2: The Shadow Unleashed. This is the "Red Wedding" moment. By killing Henry, the group unknowingly breaks the leash. Without Henry’s human ego to contain it, the Mind Flayer returns to its true, ancient roots: The Shadow Entity. No more "meat spider," no more "creature feature." The sky over Hawkins doesn't just turn red; it turns a deep, bruised purple, and a massive, incomprehensible, swirling chaos begins to pour out of the rifts. It doesn't want to rule; it wants to erase. The victory turns to ash in their mouths as they realize that Henry Creel was actually the only thing keeping the real monster at bay.
3. The Hive Army: A Real Apocalypse
Where were the legions? For the "end of the world," the enemy presence felt a little thin in the actual finale. A few vines here, a bat there. I wanted the "Upside Down" to live up to the name—a literal mirror world of nightmares.
Once the Shadow is unleashed, the entire hive mind should have woken up in a frenzy. I wanted to see thousands of Demodogs pouring through the cracks in the streets of Hawkins. I wanted the sky to be literally blackened by swarms of Demobats so thick you can't see the sun. The landscape should be a living carpet of teeth and claws.
The group shouldn't be fighting to "save the day" at this point; they should be in a frantic, claustrophobic race for survival. Every shadow is a threat. Every corner of the town is infested. This forces the party into a high-speed retreat back into the heart of the Upside Down to try and seal the source, turning the final hour into a breathless suicide mission where winning isn't the goal—just surviving long enough to try one last thing.
4. The Heartbreaker: Will Byers Comes Home
We all knew a major sacrifice was coming, but the one we got felt... safe. It was a character we loved, but it didn't fundamentally change the DNA of the story. To me, Stranger Things started with Will Byers in that shed, and it had to end with him.
Imagine the group is cornered at the "mega-rift." The swarm is seconds away from tearing them apart. The portal back to the right-side-up is right there, but the Shadow is spilling through it, beginning to dissolve our world. Will realizes something the others don't—he can still feel the buzzing in his neck, louder than it's ever been. He realizes his connection to the Mind Flayer wasn't a curse; it was a tether.
He stops running. He lets go of Mike’s hand. While the others scream for him, he turns back toward the darkness and walks into the center of the storm. He uses his trauma, his "True Sight," and his unique link to the hive mind to force the Shadow back into the Abyss.
Will doesn't die as a victim. He dies as the hero who "held the door" from the inside. As the dimension collapses and the gate seals, the psychic backlash is too much for a human mind to bear. He saves Hawkins, but he belongs to the Upside Down now. It’s haunting, it’s permanent, and it brings his arc full circle: the boy who was taken finally chooses to stay so that no one else ever has to go missing again.
5. Eleven’s Soul: The Kali (008) Confrontation
The return of Eight felt like a checkbox in the real show—a brief cameo that didn't matter. But Kali and Eleven represent the two paths for a survivor: vengeful rage vs. protective love.
In my version, Kali returns as a dark mirror. Sensing the chaos, she arrives not to help, but to "recruit" El. She uses her illusions to play on El’s deepest insecurities, showing her visions of a world where the humans (the military, the townspeople) will always fear her and eventually turn on her. When Hopper tries to pull El back, Kali snaps. She forces Hopper to relive the death of his daughter, Sara, over and over in a cruel, psychological loop.
Eleven is forced to make a choice that defines who she is. To save her father, she has to use her powers to stop her sister permanently. There is no "superhero" pose here. It’s a messy, tragic, tear-filled moment. It solidifies that Hopper is her true family, but it leaves a permanent scar on her soul. She chooses love, but she learns that love requires the hardest sacrifices.
6. The Real Epilogue: No More Lab Rats
The 45-minute "goodbye" we got was far too soft. It felt like the ending of a different, gentler show where the government just lets "dangerous assets" go live in a cabin. The reality is, the US Military wouldn't just pack up their trucks because the monsters are gone. To them, Eleven is still a multi-billion dollar biological weapon.
Instead of a peaceful timeskip, the immediate aftermath of Will’s sacrifice should have been a final, rage-fueled stand against the human villains. Grief-stricken and done with being a "test subject," Eleven turns her full power on the arriving military forces led by Dr. Kay.
This gives the character of Dr. Kay a purpose—she becomes the final symbol of the "Lab." We see Eleven systematically dismantling the project. She’s not just killing; she’s liberating. She crushes the weapons, grounds the helicopters, and burns the files. It symbolizes the end of the "lab rat" era. She finally earns her freedom not because they gave it to her, but because she became too powerful for them to ever cage again.
7. Clarifying the Lore (Dimension X)
We shouldn't have to watch a stage play in London or read a comic book to understand the lore of a show we've invested a decade into. We needed a dedicated, visual sequence—perhaps triggered by Will’s final connection—showing young Henry’s arrival in Dimension X.
We needed to see the Abyss before it was the "Upside Down." We needed to see it as a neutral, beautiful, and terrifying ecosystem before Henry corrupted it with his own malice. Seeing Henry find the Mind Flayer and realize he could "shape" it would have grounded the entire series. It would have shown us that the monsters weren't "evil" until a human mind taught them how to be. Without this, the lore feels like a puzzle with the most important pieces missing.
Stranger Things will always be a legendary piece of pop culture. It defined an era of streaming and made us all nostalgic for a time many of us never even lived through. But "good" isn't "perfect," and "safe" isn't "satisfying."
I wanted a finale that had the grit and the narrative courage that made Season 1 and Season 4 so incredible. I wanted an ending that felt like a masterpiece—one that we’d still be debating twenty years from now, not just a "decent wrap-up" that we forget by next month.
But hey, that’s just my heart talking. What about you guys? Do you think the show was right to give everyone a "happy" ending, or were you like me—wishing for something a little darker, a little deeper, and a lot more like Will Byers? Let’s talk about it in the comments. I need to know I’m not the only one who still hasn't left Hawkins behind.
No comments:
Post a Comment